Performance Marketing Effectiveness: Originality and Transculturation beyond Translation

Consulting Blog Hispanics Keep Up

Tony D’Andrea, PhD, Director of Research and Planning – San Jose Consulting

This article reflects Performance Marketing research and media behavior discussed when it was originally published in 2011.

Language, Content and Media Choices

When developing Hispanic ad campaigns, marketing executives must make key decisions over language, content and media channels.

The trend in creative development has been in producing original targeted Hispanic spots that integrate cultural insights into messaging, talent and media behavior, or in transculturating general market (“universal” truth) assets in ways that incorporate cultural nuance into a relevant conversation with Hispanics. And results are tangible. In fact, recent studies by AHAA demonstrate a positive correlation between Hispanic media spending and general corporate revenues.

Yet, the road is long and many marketers still prefer to learn by trial and error. Let’s consider two radical scenarios and some likely results. In the first case, you decide to save money by merely translating your general market assets into Spanish with no further considerations over messaging, talent or production. Result: the performance of your ads may suffer by more than 40%, according to recent research by Millward Brown. Still, let’s consider a more drastic scenario, in which you bluntly decide to reach Hispanics via English-language media only, “after all, most Hispanics are bilingual and they must be watching tons of TV in English.” As a rule of thumb (based on Nielsen), roughly half of Hispanics spend half of their TV time in each language (even as only 17% of all Hispanics prefer to speak English at home). However, when bilingual Latinos watch English-language TV, ad recall and likeability drop by more than 20% and 30% on average compared to Spanish-language media, according to a study by Nielsen AIG. In addition, reach across the Hispanic population is lower in general market TV, covering 38% of all Hispanics over one month (instead of 50% in Spanish media), and among Spanish-dominant Hispanics the reach is 20% instead of 80%!

Originality and Transculturation vs. Simple Translation

Given such striking differences, what is the right model for advertising to Hispanics?

We recognize that some translated ads can be successful in Spanish media, and that English ads in the general market media can also catch their attention. Nonetheless, as a basic generalization, we can say that if a brand seeks to positively connect with bilingual Hispanics, advertising in Spanish is necessary by means of original or transculturated messages. If true, what is to be gained with this approach? Based on our analysis of Nielsen AIG and Millward Brown data, on average…

Historical Performance Findings

  • Hispanic reach: the cited research found higher reach when Spanish-language media was used, especially among Spanish-dominant Hispanics.
  • Ad recall: Spanish-language media produced stronger recall in the studies referenced at the time.
  • Ad likeability: culturally relevant Spanish-language executions also tested more favorably than comparable general-market ads.
  • Targeted ads: original or transculturated creative generally outperformed simple translations.

In sum, your chances of achieving a top performing ad in Spanish media increases by 85% if it is original or transculturated advertising, one that directly connects with Hispanic needs, values and aspirations.

Beyond statistical evidence, our direct experience with English-dominant Hispanics is also revealing. As noted in domestic interviews and focus groups, they are hugely in favor of commercials in Spanish language and explain that, unlike themselves, their parents and neighbors may not speak English. But this is not just about language but rather in reaching a consumer segment meaningfully. A marketer that advertises original or transculturated messages in Spanish will most probably yield superior results among the 51 million Hispanics in the U.S. As such, the nuances of multicultural marketing call for an effective and culturally relevant approach.

Applying the Principle Today

The central lesson still holds: language choice alone is not a substitute for cultural relevance. San Jose Consulting’s Consumer Insights and Communications and Convergent Marketing Solutions help brands connect audience insight, messaging and channel strategy rather than relying on translation alone.

Creative ApproachStrategic Risk or Benefit
Direct translationFast, but may lose cultural nuance, tone and relevance.
Original in-language creativeCan reflect audience insight from the start.
TransculturationPreserves a core brand idea while adapting cultural context meaningfully.
English-only outreachMay miss language-preference and media-behavior differences within the audience.

Frequently Asked Questions

Are the performance percentages in this article current?

No. They reflect research available when the article was published and are preserved as historical context.

Is translation always ineffective?

No. The issue is whether the translated execution still feels relevant, natural and aligned with the audience and brand.

What should marketers test today?

Test language, cultural context, creative approach, media environment and business outcomes with current audience data.

From Creative Choice to Business Decision

The practical question is not whether every campaign should be in Spanish, English or bilingual. It is which approach creates the strongest combination of relevance, reach and business impact for the specific audience. San Jose Consulting’s Assessment and Brand Growth Solutions can help connect creative and audience choices to the broader brand-growth strategy, while current testing should validate which execution performs best in-market.

A disciplined test can compare message comprehension, recall, brand fit and conversion across creative approaches. That makes the decision less about assumptions regarding language and more about measurable performance with the intended audience.